An innovative new way to grow microalgae could help overcome barriers that limit its commercial viability in products such as biofuels and animal feeds.
Byron Bay's Karl Lawton is on the point of a breakthrough in the leading-edge science of microalgae bioreactors. Not bad for a bloke who only completed Year 12.
“If I’m asked at a dinner party what I do, I say I’m designing and building a biofilm-based enclosed bioreactor,” says Karl. “And that’s when the dinner party guests go, ‘Well, what the hell is that?’ And I say, ‘I can’t really go into it because we’re still working through the patent process …’”
Karl Lawton is the 54-year-old director of Byron Bioreactor Technologies. His company is 4 years old, and together with a small team of one PhD student and a handful of advisers, he has designed and built a new system for growing microalgae – one that potentially leaves existing systems in its wake.
At this point, rather like Karl’s metaphorical dinner party guests, you may require a little background.
‘Microalgae’ is a collective noun that describes hundreds of thousands of species of single-cell phytoplankton that typically photosynthesise in water or sediment. They’re invisible to the naked eye and sit at the bottom of the food chain but, as science has come to realise, they’re a tremendous bio-resource.
Harvested in sufficient quantity, microalgae could be used in human nutrition, as well as feedstock for biofuel and fodder for animals and fish.
They don’t ask for much in their growth cycle, requiring only some basic nutrients, carbon dioxide and water. And if their environment is altered (for instance, if the nutrient levels are varied) some species can be goaded into producing valuable products for use in pharmaceuticals and cosmetics. So far, so good.
Unfortunately, they require sterile growing conditions and their water consumption-to-yield ratio can be prohibitive. Moreover, it's difficult to grow them in sufficient densities to be commercially viable for high-consumption/low-cost markets such as animal fodder.
At present, microalgae species are commercially grown in water-based ‘photobioreactors’, usually raised in closed or semi-closed tanks, tubes and ponds.
A biofilm design for growth
But in June 2022, Byron Bioreactor Technologies filed an international patent application for its design of a new system. There are still patent processes to be gone through and Karl is guarded about how the new design works.
This much he can tell us: it’s an enclosed panel measuring one metre by one metre and 500mm deep; it’s lightweight; and it’s modular and scalable, such that a grower could potentially stack 20 panels to reach the ceiling of a 10m-tall shed.
Key to all this is the fact that the Byron system no longer relies on algae being grown in water.
“We’re growing microalgae as a biofilm – so it’s being grown on a surface, says Karl. "Because the system is enclosed, it’s protected from the environment to ensure it’s sterile. And it’s also fully controllable in terms of light, nutrients and water.”
Compared to existing systems, Karl’s design ensures the microalgae is watered but is not grown in suspension, so it uses a fraction of the water. It also consumes 25-50% fewer nutrients. He says inoculation of the panel is easy, species can be swapped in and out, and sterile conditions can be maintained.
Critically, the biofilm system allows for cheaper and more efficient harvesting.
“With existing submerged systems you end up with a whole lot of water and a little bit of microalgae – and the yield has still got to be separated. When we harvest, we’re harvesting a paste, which is 15-30% of the cost per kilogram. And production is more concentrated.”
At this stage, productivity comparisons are tricky. Karl says water-based systems measure their yield in grams per litre, whereas biofilm system productivity is measured by footprint (i.e. by the square metre). Nonetheless, like for like, he estimates his system increases yield by a factor of five.
At this stage, Karl’s dinner party guests would be forgiven for assuming he’s a trained scientist or an engineer with a row of letters after his name.
Pathway to a new business
“I don’t have a science background,” he says simply. “When I left school, all I ever knew was that I wanted to run my own business. I just didn’t know what.”
Karl’s career pathway is best described as "unlikely’" He grew up on a Merino sheep farm near Canberra, and had some interest in cropping and volunteered with Landcare. He also had a restless spirit and an insatiable curiosity, one that was satisfied by magazines like New Scientist and, increasingly, the ever-expanding universe that would become the internet.
He worked for the greater part doing agricultural jobs – including maintaining greenhouses, growing hibiscus flowers, tree planting and labouring on organic farms. But he also sat business courses and pursued projects. Three of these projects would come to exert an influence on his critical thinking and his skillset.
In the 1990s, Karl was part of operations to grow hemp. Even though the plant was "politically a bit on the nose", he helped persuade Goulburn City Council to approve a two-acre trial site beside a sewage treatment facility.
“They sprayed treated effluent on the hemp plants and they grew really, really well. But the project got out of control when locals thought we were growing marijuana, not hemp, so it started to break down from there.
“I could see the benefits in hemp because it’s a multiple end-use crop. And that’s effectively what microalgae is – a multiple end-use crop.”
In the 2000s, he teamed up with a performer and started doing "art/science performances" around the country. “We’d create heavy vibrations – sine waves – using equipment we borrowed from the Australian Defence Force Academy. We’d put these waves through containers of water or plates spread with glitter or sand, to create these amazing geometric patterns. The higher the frequency, the more complex the pattern. We were basically moving molecules and showing that movement in glitter and water.”
They performed at the Questacon science museum in Canberra and earned rave reviews. At a show in Byron, one member of the audience was so impressed he offered Karl a workshop and a place to live so he could continue his art/science development.
“Within two weeks, I’d packed up my life and moved to Byron.”
Above: Karl Lawton and his experiments with sine wave patterns, which eventually led him to microalgae and the development of new bioreactor technology. Photos: Karl Lawton
Karl’s new benefactor had a business making concrete ‘flowforms’. These organically shaped forms are used to naturally mix and ‘enhance the energies’ of fertiliser and water, a practice used in biodynamic farming. Karl started making these flowforms, gaining knowledge in making moulds, formwork and the business of diverting water.
All the while he was still feeding his hunger for knowledge. “I’m a researcher at heart,” he says, “I just can’t help myself – whether it’s the latest 3D-printing technologies, business models or how the human mind works …”
In 2017, Karl became particularly excited by microalgae, and how it could be grown in controlled environments.
“Typically in the farming game, you’re exposed to uncertainties – the markets, the weather, all the middlemen and other players.
"With microalgae, you’ve got full control over every aspect of its growth and its quality. If a market isn’t going to play nicely, or there are too many competitors, you can adapt to the prevailing conditions," says Karl Lawton.
"You can swap out to a different species of microalgae, or start focusing on a different value component – you can move into vaccines or an oil or a commodity-based market like animal feed or fish feed.”
That’s when Karl turned his attention to the design of photobioreactors.
“I looked at what was commercially available and the designs just didn’t feel right. Then I came across biofilm systems. That was my lightbulb moment when I went ‘Ohhhh, okay — you can grow microalgae as a biofilm! Well, that presents an opportunity to do this and this and this …’
“Perhaps it’s because I don’t have a science background, I was able to see a way that was different. I think if you go through more traditional [academic pathways], you’re sort of directed to think there are only so many solutions available to you – solutions that have been researched and done a certain way.”
Pilot scale proof-of-concept
Starting with simple design concepts, Karl began experimenting and steadily increasing complexity. Then he marshalled some powerful resources. He took an accelerated business course at UTS in Sydney, sought federal and state funding and began collaborating with mechanical engineering student Alex Sokolov (who had advertised on LinkedIn for a suitable undergraduate project).
Now Karl is engaging a wider network of academics and researchers as a partner in the Marine Bioproducts Cooperative Research Centre (MBCRC).
“The MBCRC is about refining the system,” he says. “I’ve got a pilot-scale proof of concept and I’ve got everything to work; the researchers at MBCRC have the expertise and the technology to find out about different forces and movement within the bioreactor. So now it’s about using simulation and experimentation to really optimise the system. We need to understand what it can do and measure its competitiveness against other bioreactors.”
[ Read more: Co-operative research to kickstart marine bioindustries ]
Karl says he anticipates pilot scale systems to be demonstrating production within 18 months and systems in production by 2025. He realises there are strong commercial opportunities in the manufacture and sale of his design, but says he’s more motivated by the production of microalgae biomass and extraction of compounds.
“Who would have thought microalgae would be so exciting? There’s so many opportunities in so many market spaces – in medicine, in food, in animal feed …
“Microalgae has this huge potential to benefit the planet and people. It’s good to be of service to that,” Karl says.
MAGICAL MICROALGAE - POTENTIAL USES
Food production: The Aztecs used cultures of Arthrospira (Spirulina) maxima to make a type of cake named tecuitlatl. Natives of Chad used the same species to prepare a foodstuff named dihe. And Nostoc flagelliforme has been eaten in China for 2000 years as fa cai.
Animal feed: Species of microalgae have huge potential as animal feed supplements owing to the presence of amino acids, carotenoids and vitamins, enhancing the nutritional quality of the animal products.
High-value compound production: Microalgae species are currently producing β-carotene, astaxanthin, docosahexaenoic acid (DHA), eicosahexaenoic acid, phycobilin pigments and algal extracts for use in cosmetics. They’re also increasingly playing a role in cosmeceuticals and nutraceuticals.
Waste remediation: Microalgae has the capability to grow in nutrient-rich environments and accumulate nutrients and metals which can be recovered for reuse.
Wastewater remediation: Microalgae is a suitable remedial agent because it can easily remove toxic substances, has high biosorption capabilities and has less nutritional requirements than fungi and bacteria. It’s also non-toxic.
Biofuels: Microalgae has the ability to produce carbohydrates and lipids which can be used in the production of gaseous and liquid biofuels including butanol, ethanol, methane and hydrogen.
Fertiliser: Microalgae contains organic matter, especially amino acids and phytohormones in addition to polysaccharides, useful as biostimulants in growing higher plants.
More information: Byron Bioreactor Technologies, NSW
This article was first published in the Marine Bioproducts CRC newsletter Just One Drop and is reproduced here with permission. (Some minor edits have been made for style.)